I was inspired yesterday during my French exam. Continuing on this theme of controvery I seem to have started, I will now write here some of the same ideas I expressed on my exam. Basically we had to read an article in a really cool Quebecois magazine called L’actualité, that dealt with homosexual child prostitution in Lebanon. The article is called “Quand le Liban fait la pute” by Katia Jarjoura p. 50 on the March 15th edition. Most of the articles on the magazine can be found online, but for some reason I can’t find this one. The question I had to answer for my essay was if I believed, like journalist Souhaib Ayyoub had suggested in the article, that religious oppression of sex had something to do with this problem…
So here is a quick translation/summary of the article:
“I was sixteen the first time,” says Marwan, a young man who with his appeal, could easily pass for a rock star in America. He explains that he was in Tripoli driving in a car with his friends when they introduced him to a Saudi business man. He wanted Marwan to give him a blowjob. At first Marwan refused but he was so poor and so desperate that he ended up accepting. He made $250 US dollars and hasn’t stopped since. In this town about 80 km north of the capital of Beruth, his story is not a unique one. According to him, around 50% of the people in Tripoli are paid for sexual services.
Thanks to Marwan and his friends’ good looks they have had some very high paying customers, including religious men, family men, business men, and even princes. Interestingly enough, the vast majority of their customers come from Saudi Arabia, a land of strict religious beliefs, of incredible gender segregation and inequality where women can show nothing but their eyes. They say that for the most part they are treated kindly; they have sex, get paid, and leave. They make anywhere between $500 to $2500 US depending on the social status of the client. This is five times more than the average Lebanese income of $300 per month.
The origin of this vicious cycle these kids are trapped in is of course poverty and misery. One boy was arrested after hitting a client who was trying to abuse him. Of course in jail, his cover stories include drugs or theft, because if he admitted to being a prostitute he would undoubtedly be killed. “Prostitution is taboo in Islam,” says Ayyoub. He wrote an article about “sexual deviance” and religious oppression for which he was publicly denounced, sheiks ridiculed him during sermons, etc. He argues that the gender segregation and the unyielding religious fundamentalism is what creates in the youth a boiling desire to escape and rebel.
Well, if you know me at all, I think you know what my opinion is on this one. I strongly agree that, yes, religious oppression has a lot to do with this “sexual deviance.” I hate calling it that, but they called it that in the article. To me sexual deviance refers to both the act of paying for sex/being payed for sex and homosexuality..which is why I don’t like it. I highly doubt this is what the author intended by “sexual deviance” though, or at least I hope.
Anyways, in my exam I compared this situation with the whole child molestation issue with the Catholic church. It has a lot of the same components: repression of sexual desires and oppression by the church..really just the whole idea of making sex taboo just baffles me. Violence is cool, whatever, but sex… dear God save our souls from such a nasty sinful act!! It really all just boils down to the most basic concept of human psychology: people want to do what they are not allowed to do! You’d think we would have gotten the hint by now. We all have an innate psychological need for autonomy, competence and relatedness. When religion (or parents!) tries to take away two of these fundamental needs each and every human being on this earth possess, they are going to rebel. Just like you take action when someone steals something from you or when someone offends you or the ones you love, you are going to REACT if someone takes away your freedom and/or stops you from fulfilling your need for human contact.
Let me give you a very simple example to make this as clear as possible: when you are 14 or 15 you are not allowed to drink…so you seek it out, you get way too drunk because you have absolutely no idea of how it will affect you, your parents have never given you an explanation other than “it’s bad for you, it makes you do stupid things.” Well…that sounds like quite a thrill to me! So you get absolutely plastered. You are then punished for it (I’m not going to get into how incredibly ineffective punishment is right now… that will be a whole other entry) and just find more sneaky ways to do it. Now lets take sex (and I’m talking about consensual sex right now). Again, you are 14 or 15 and your parents and your religion have always told you sex is an act of the devil. Jesus, Mary and Joseph..you’re going to hell for this shit! Television shows and films are rated 18A for sexual content but PG when Rambo decapitates people left, right, and centre. Messages that sex is evil are bombarded into your head faster than Rambo’s AK47 can splatter 100 Vietnamese prisoners’ guts all over your TV screen. Of course you’re going to want to know what this “sex” thing is all about, but since you know absolutely nothing about it because no one has ever talked to you about it you’ll probably end up pregnant or with a nice little STI. Good times!
Something is very wrong with this picture. I suppose it works for the porn industry though…they make a killing out of the taboo. If sex weren’t a taboo the porn industry would not exist.
I have a point about prostitution, I promise.
Homosexuality is a taboo in Islam. But not only in Islam, I know in Paraguay, where Catholicism reigns supreme, basically anything to do with sex, whether homosexual or heterosexual, is not spoken of. People are taught to be ashamed of their sexual desires, especially if they are directed towards a member of the same sex. Much like not being allowed to have a drink with dinner, a safe controlled environment where you can experiment with alcohol’s effects, harbouring feelings of shame and guilt surrounding sex will only make people rebel and fight back for their freedom of expression. Do you think that if these rich businessmen and these clergymen hadn’t been made to think that homosexuality is a thing of the devil and that sex will make you burn in hell they would be releasing their frustrations on harmless little boys? Of course not! They would know that what they are feeling is normal, that people are different and that God loves everyone equally, that everybody deserves to be happy. They would instead find a consensual and unpaid partner their own age (and not easy, powerless targets like children) and practice safe sex because they would be educated about it since it wouldn’t be taboo! So simple! Yet so complicated.
It’s frustrating. It makes me want to bitch slap some people and tell them to just open up their minds…to free their minds from societal pressures which are so often detrimental to our mental health and well being. To stop being brainwashed by texts written thousands and thousands of years ago that have been translated so many times by so many different people all with their own little brainwashed ideas of what God supposedly wants.
I’ll leave you with the last paragraph of the article.
“All the money I make I end up spending right away. I can’t keep this dirty money, it’s embarrassing. If I could still dream today, I would wish for everyone to forget me, and start back at zero.”- Marwan.